Tuesday, August 23, 2022

October 31…The Smartest Kids in the World

Use this space to do a little thinking/writing about what you've seen so far in The Smartest Kids in the World documentary. You can write about what it seems to be saying about the purposes of school, the other themes of our class, its international perspective, or the film as a piece of education and/or popculture. You also could (but are not obligated to) react to this short, highly critical review in light of what you have seen so far.  

23 comments:

  1. While watching The smartest kids in the world the main characters really had the same reasons why they wanted to travel somewhere else rather than to keep going to U.S schools because they feel as though they are not learning to their full poteninal of they just want a challenge. But once they cross over school and go to another countries they start to face harder challenges then expected while going to these new schools.we spend alot of money on our school system to be ranked in a low area in all three subjects.they feel as though since we spend so much going into education why arent the results showing for it or why dont i feel like im learning anything.

    ReplyDelete
  2. After watching the beginning of the documentary, I found it to be a deep dive in American students wanting more out of their education, so they decide to travel abroad to challenge themselves. As they start to immerse themselves in the schools in foreign countries, they face new challenges that they weren’t expecting. So far this film highlights that actually having a trusting relationship within the school creates a significantly more comfortable environment, which seemingly in this film, is better for education. It also raises the question of “why is the American education system ranking so low when we are spending significant amounts of money when other countries are succeeding at a much lower cost?” I hope that they address this more throughout the rest of the documentary.

    ReplyDelete
  3. After watching the beginning of the documentary I noticed that all the students were seeking the same thing, a challenging academic school environment. They traveled to different countries to pursue a more challenging academic environment and they found that it was different than they had imagined. The students from America seem to believe that the only way to succeed is to be in a more challenging and intensive environment. In Finland, for example, they prioritize the well-being of the students and staff, unlike in America where students are used to working difficult and long hours for school. Even though in America we spend two times as much on education It’s still ranking low, unlike other countries that spend less on education.

    ReplyDelete
  4. After watching the start of the smartest kids in the world, I was genuinely surprised how the students reacted and responded to a different school’s environment. I excepted the students to be relived to be out of such a hard school system- it’s pretty well known I feel that American school systems are factory like with a lot of work pushed onto students, so I feel the element of looking for a “challenge” in other schooling is misplaced- other than the language barrier I feel other schools in other countries are more trusting in students- and the general population. But I don’t think it’s something we could apply in America- not in public schools at least. It’s comes back to the way our society is in America in general, and I don’t think their system could work here.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel that the film highlights the problems within the American school system but also glamorizes/romanticizes foreign schooling. Especially because some of the differences are just cultural and not necessarily choices independent of people in charge of education. I do like how they treat high school aged children overseas like young adults but I feel like this also might be attributed to culture because some places are safer than others so it is okay to have a minor out by themselves. I though the one girl who was talking about not learning real life skills in the US was interesting. I feel like many people complain that school doesn't teach you real life things and that you will never use algebra etc. I feel that aside from people who are math majors for example something like algebra can teach you new ways of thinking or sometimes concepts in more important classes will build off that. I find that often times people complaining about those things are simply complaining because the subject is hard for them and not necessarily because that is what they truly believe. I also don't understand why that girl had to go overseas to learn "life skills" in her case I feel like she could have had her parents home school her/supplement her public school education with what she was looking for since she had already been homeschooled before. -celine gorkowski

    ReplyDelete
  6. I feel like they are above average when it comes to school and the want to be somewhere where they feel challenged. They get bored with stuffs easily and they love competitions and challenges. - (This comment is by Keziah Yeboah)

    ReplyDelete
  7. From what I've seen so far in the documentary I can kind of see some similarities with what I went through in public schools as well. When I was younger I went to a public school that, honestly, was so far behind what the regular standard of education should be that I was so ahead of most of the curriculum my parents decide to have my sister and I transfer to another school district. Immediately I noticed a difference in the difficulty and quality of education I received and it made a huge difference in challenge me to study and work harder. My parents have also noticed many things in the american education system that they find strange or even sometimes over complicated as opposed to the foreign schools they attended. For example, the way they teach us math here is way more complicated than overseas and learning from my parents is way easier to me than learning in class. I think these some of the areas where the US lacks in but can improve for sure. I think this documentary can be enlightening to many of us that aren't aware of what the U.S. education system lacks because it's what they grew up with and have only experienced.

    ReplyDelete
  8. One of the aspects I was pleasantly surprised by was how the foreign schools with the superior rankings were depicted. I was expecting the main thrust of why these school were so successful to be explained as "The students are most disciplined, they pay attention, put in more work, and sacrifice their social life for their schooling. But the any clip we see of Finnish students is a group of students doing tricks on dirt bikes, something that would be rebellious by American standards. I do wonder if that depiction will change as we see the other foreign schools, maybe they will show a more disciplined view of education.
    I wasn't about to read the whole article because of a pay wall, but I did see that it complained that the reliability of the metrics used by studies cited weren't proven to the audience, and therefore, seemed unreliable to the writer. While I didn't doubt the PISA system of quantifying education, I did think that another aspect of the documentary should have a qualification on it, and that was the ranking of the United States' spending on students. While the US may spend more more money per student than any other country, the data are more complicated. In addition to exchanging local currency to USD in that calculation, Purchasing power parity (PPP) should also be taken into account. PPP is how far a dollar goes in a particular country, and is usually less in countries outside the US because of cheaper labor, among other factors. With PPP taken into account, I think it may be the case that some other countries with higher rankings might actually spend more than the US, this doesn't excuse the US's poor performance, but it's an important piece of the data

    ReplyDelete
  9. While watching this documentary, I realized that the kids who wanted to study abroad wanted a more immersive education, whether that be learning at a higher difficulty or more attention to their education in general. However, it seemed like not everyone is getting what they wanted. One girl thought the school she travelled to wasn't doing enough educational-wise because of the frequent breaks throughout the day, but hat school had higher test scores than America. It makes me think that part of the reason our test scores are the way they are is because of the unnecessarily rigid structures of our schools. Schools may intend to have the students' best interests in mind, but this often backfires and leads to students finding loopholes.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think this documentary was very much needed and informative of how under-developed our country is educationally. We almost never see children who actually care about learning and their education system. It is a great thing they are doing to help other students like them. By studying abroad, this will allow the students to receive a new outlook on other educational systems. With this information, they can compare to the US and help our educational system.

    ReplyDelete
  11. While watching this documentary I found it very interesting to see how many students were seeking higher education. This really says a lot about how the American school system really fails students who excel in certain areas of the curriculum. I found it even more interesting that when the American students went to other countries to further their education, they found themselves ill prepared for what they were being taught in these new school systems.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I found it interesting how this documentary was honest about how schooling outside of the United States isn't always the superior alternative for students. I recall one of the students finding out she actually preferred the rigorous 8-hour days of school in America over the more relaxed day where you are sleeping in and home from school by 4 o'clock. It isn't a secret that the U.S. school systems are lacking, but we don't often consider how the students have sort of been conditioned to crave this hard work. They get so used to their entire life being dedicated to school that sometimes, too much freedom will leave them feeling restless.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Watching the beginning of this documentary and seeing that these American students wanted to expand their education further didn't really surprise me. I feel like a lot of our education here in the United States is restrictive and disorganized. While there are disadvantages in foreign education, at least there are more options out there. The American school system tends to lean towards teaching to make us all obedient, hard working citizens and while these students in the documentary appreciate that, I can understand the strive to find what we are doing wrong. I did notice that this documentary opened my eyes the more I watched the reactions of the student abroad. In observing their experiences, it seems the more schools trust their students and allow more leeway, the more respect there is in the learning environment. I think to be good citizens and workers, young students need to be heard more and respected, which is what the other nations seem to be doing better with than the United States.

    ReplyDelete
  14. So far, this documentary has given me some new perspective on how the education system in the United States compares to schooling in other countries. It has pointed out many significant flaws, but the thing that stood out the most to me is the emphasis that the United States puts on standardized testing and grades. I found it so interesting that other countries (with arguably better education systems) do not rely on testing as much as our country does. I think that standardized testing is not healthy for students because it teaches them to memorizes and compete against each other constantly rather than actually learning the material. Something else that really stood out to me was that other countries allow students to decide if they want to retake a grade/class in order to get a better understanding rather than having the system/a student's parents decide for them. I feel like if that happened in the U.S., so many more students would feel supported in their efforts to succeed rather than feeling like a failure.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think the smartest kids in the world documentary is saying that school is supposed to be about learning but as we see a lot of the main kids in the film study abroad because they don’t feel like schools in the US really achieve what school is supposed to be about. I think a common thing that I see in this documentary film is that the main students really do want to learn; a lot of kids in the US take education for granite and don’t really care about school, but these kids seem to really have a hunger for education and progressing in that area. And I feel like a lot of people and students feel that other places have better education because they see the results of education in the US and it’s not as strong as other countries and that’s why the students of course are choosing to study in different areas around the world.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sorry that it is late, I will shoot you an email. My life got a little bit crazy. The documentary " The smartest kids in the world" aims to offer an education worldwide but it lacks economic and cultural information. American students want more out of their education, so they study abroad but are faced with challenges they did not expect. After watching the beginning of the documentary, I noticed that all the students want the same thing and don't understand why they spend so much time and money in education to not gain much back.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This documentary caused me to thoroughly reflect about my past in K-12. The culture of sacrificing time with friends, family, and extracurriculars to solely increase test scores permeated through the halls. I can understand sacrifices for education as a whole and to increase your knowledge but increasing that and test scores are two different things. If American schools emphasized the importance of one’s education for personal growth rather than bragging rights for the county, country, parents, or even the person learning, I think students would collectively have a different outlook on their education. As I grow older, I understand the significance of education more clearly and why it is so crucial for it to be accessible and safe.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Tatiana Yarborough
    While watching The Smartest kids in the world, I've watched these kids take their education into their own hands by choosing to fly across the country for a better education. While in their new homes and schools they discovered that learning in these new environments is harder than they expected. Some began to experience doubts about their abilities and questions about whether they still wanted to continue in the program. Seeing the way education is handled in these other countries makes me realize that American education was never truly about the students learning the information but rather making sure they can remember information well enough to perform on tests, which clearly is not working as well as everyone thought.

    ReplyDelete
  19. After watching The Smartest Kids in the World, I related to the documentary in the way of feeling like I didn't get enough out of my education. I was happy that the kids were able to advocate for themselves and took the opportunity to see what else is available to them. I found it interesting that students wanted to do more work though haha. In school I felt that a lot of our extra work was busy work, when we could've taken that time to really apply the information.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Watching this documentary made me really realize how public schools in the United States could definitely improve. I think schools in the US are really screwed up and don't focus on teaching what is really important in life. In the documentary, it showed how differently these schools teach and what the teach. They get taught music, have more guidance, and the students have more say in what classes they take or if they want to repeat the course. It seems like the schools main goal for the students is for them to be overall well-rounded students. Overall, I enjoyed the film because it opened my understanding to teaching outside the US but made me mad at the same time because I know we can do better especially the money we have that goes towards our school compared to most other countries.

    ReplyDelete
  21. After watching The Smartest Kids In The World, I found myself thinking about my experience with the American education system. For me, school always felt like a chore and was extremely boring. I feel like a lot of American students feel like this due to the way the system feels robotic and doesn't feel like a space that encourages creativity or curiosity. The documentary talks about how in Finland they focus on the health of both the teachers and the students. Putting an emphasis on mental and physical well-being fosters a better school environment that students want to spend time and learn. Which could be why even though the funding is higher for American schools, the performance/testing levels are lower than other countries.

    ReplyDelete

August 29…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...