Tuesday, August 23, 2022

September 5…Hollywood Goes to High School

Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.)  in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. Note: If you absolutely can’t find something to disagree with, feel free to write about that situation (why you can’t disagree) or simply discuss something that you found interesting in Ch. 1. 

26 comments:

  1. On Pg.8 paragraph 3 Bulman states that he believes that individualism is a dominant theme in these high school movies, I disagree. As he mentioned earlier with blackboard jungle, most of these movies revolve around a teacher making kids conform to what is expected of them. While I can also see that these movies do often show individualism; I wouldn’t say it’s a dominant theme or anything that is changed in the movie. Kids are individuals, and they do indeed gain more traits and comfort within themselves, but in the end the goal is to conform to what is expected of them, what is expected of all children in school, to pass no mater what.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In paragraph 3 on Pg 4 Bulman said we should represent our confusion in our social life in folktales and ficiton I disagree with that because if we based everything in fiction and fairy tales its always gonna be a barrier between real and fake because then the world would be sugar coated and not taken seriously.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ashleigh Petry
    I found that I could not disagree with Bulman’s final claims in chapter one (pg 10). As I read this chapter, I was reflecting on films I have seen and how the student/teacher/academic relationships differed. Two of his final statements mentioned how the poor and/or working class (urban) schools have more of a heroic teacher centered role which lines up with the movie, Dangerous Minds. This movie also leans more on the teacher having a positive effect on the students academic progress and because of the academic progress, the students gain personal development as well but it was not necessarily the initial focus. However in a film like Clueless, which is set in a rich suburban area, the main character never worried about her grades farther than pleasing her father so she can go out to social events. Furthermore, the teachers do not play a significant role in the students’ lives. All in all, I could not disagree with the fact that academic pressure and teacher/school staff involvement certainly differ within social class conditions in film.

    ReplyDelete
  4. After reading chapter 1 page 8, I found myself disagreeing with Bulman’s point about individualism. He states that most high school films focus on the individualism in the main character. While I do think a lot of films do a decent job presenting this, it is easy to forget and change a character to be just like everyone else. I see this mostly in teen films. The nerdy girl takes off her glasses and suddenly she’s beautiful and just like everyone else. I believe that this cliche is not showing individualism at all, in fact it’s showing the complete opposite. I do agree with Bulman’s point that in these films, often the character has the ability to have academic achievement if they find it within themselves regardless of what else is going on in their lives. But again this isn’t really showing individualism, it’s showing that every student no matter where/what they come from have the ability to be just like everyone else.

    ReplyDelete
  5. On page 3 Bulman states that " films do influence how we see the world. The commercial film industry is a socializing institution. Films teach us who we are as much as they reflect who we are". I disagree with this statement. I believe that is true for children and individuals who are still figuring out who they are. If you are confident in who you are then a film cannot reflect who you are. People may watch films and look at things different if it provides another aspect to what they are watching. But a film will not permanently change how one sees the world. I feel like real world situations change how you see the world and your reaction is a reflection of who you are.

    ReplyDelete
  6. As I read, I found myself mostly agreeing with Bulman up until his last few points on individualism. I don't have a strong disagreement with his statements but I did question a part in chapter 1, page 10 where he claimed a difference in individualism based on the genre of the high school film. He said that urban school films show "utilitarian individualism", suburban school films show "expressive individualism", and that private school films show both. I feel like in studying the individualism in these films, it can be possible for utilitarian and expressive types to coexist no matter what genre of high school film it is. While some tend to lean into one more than another, it does not mean that it should always be categorized separately between suburban and urban settings. Identity exploration, self expression, hard work, self-sufficiency, and academic achievement can all be categorized as the "dominant" individualism no matter the film type.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tatiana Yarborough
    While reading the chapter I came across a statement on page 2 about genre films. It said, "commercial interests reflect the culture as they strategically select projects, develop them, produce them and market them to the public." At first, I was going to disagree because most of the studios that fund films are run by older white men who don't truly represent the diverse culture that we live in, but as I continued thinking about it I realized that they do reflect culture. They reflect their culture which is why there are limited films about minorities.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I did not necessarily find something to disagree about, however, there was a statement about the depiction of high school in Hollywood films/tv shows. The statement read "It soon became clear that there were significant differences in the ways the students and the teachers in the urban public school, suburban public school, and private school films were depicted on the screen"- Bulman ch.1. I also agree with this statement because you can always see the clear difference of where the student on the film lives. In contrast, the films tend to focus more on the student drama/friendships but not what the actual meaning of "education" means. I believe that school can come off to its viewers as a place to hang out with/meet new friends.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I disagreed with an early statement in the article. Bulman argues that films reflect popular culture, because of how artists are affected by the culture, how commercial interests select what films to make based on the culture they're made in, and how audiences react to a certain film. I don't have a total disagreement with the statement, but I would like to add a caveat. Film doesn't reflect all of popular culture, film reflects the elements of popular culture that can glorified, dramatized, or otherwise given importance with the tools available to cinema. Some elements of our culture aren't shown in film and so would be ignored if the sociological analysis just focused solely on film. Now I'm going to undercut my point by using a piece of film (or television) as an example, but the TV Show "Mr. Show" had a sketch called Coupon: the Movie, which included executives making a movie about a coupon given how popular the coupon was, but no one saw it, because it's simply a movie about a coupon. This is an element of the popular culture that no one cares enough about to see a movie about it. Now, I don't think that Bulman means to say that film analysis is all that is necessary to understand culture, but the lack of a caveat or qualification on how effective this was what I disagreed with.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I did not like/I disagreed with Bulman’s statement about how movies and shows are modern day folk tales. I feel like modern movies/shows are meant to reflect our life to appear relatable and real whereas folktales are more cautionary or focused on the past and aren't meant to be relatable in a direct way. There are exceptions to this obviously but with the rise of YouTube vloggers I feel that there has been a shift in new TV shows (aimed at middle school/ early high school) to focus on reflecting teen life rather than providing insight/something to learn from. -- Celine Gorkowski

    ReplyDelete
  11. Something I disagreed with was Bulmans narrow view about the three archetypes of high school films, how they can only represent poor youth, middle class youth, or wealthy youth. I feel like as times progress there are many more complex issues affecting high school students regardless of what class status they might fit in. Things like race, gender, sexuality, etc., are becoming much more normalized to discuss in larger media projects like films and I feel like those give a more accurate reflection to the "American high school culture" he was referencing in the beginning of the chapter.

    ReplyDelete
  12. While reading this chapter, it occurred to me that Bulman's view on individualism in in high school and high school related films are something I disagree with. In majority of television shows and movies that I have watched show an introverted "ugly" girl who becomes outgoing and pretty because she wants to look like everyone else. Another example is the nerdy boy of the school suddenly shoots from half court in basketball and he's automatically popular and hanging with the cool kids. This to me is not individualism. It is considered as trying to fit in. Bulman also mentions how children nowadays are influenced on their individualism by what they see in films. I also disagree with this statement because to me, that is not considered individualism. I understand the point he is trying to make but he is not executing it in the right way. Instead, individualism would have been better reciprocated if he had used an example of someone who wanted to be different than everyone else they surround themselves by. That to me is individualism.

    ReplyDelete
  13. After reading chapter 1 of Bulman's Sociological Introduction to films, I disagree with his statement on page 4. He states that "Another reason that it is difficult to pinpoint the precise role that films play in a culture is that culture is complex and messy." While I don't think Bulman meant this assertion in negative way, I don't believe messy would be the right word to describe culture. Culture is the foundation of pop culture, and it is what ties our uniqueness together. Everyone has a different culture and to say that it is "messy" just because it varies from yours seems kind of closed-minded.

    ReplyDelete
  14. After reading chapter 1 of Bulman’s perspective on intro to films, I found myself disagreeing with his view on how we should represent our confusion of our social life in folktales and fiction. I disagree with because If we try to represent our social life in the matter of folktales and fiction it would get lost in translation and would make the world seem a certain way. I also think it could be influenced to fit a narrative or a way of thinking that’s unrealistic and could lead to becoming problematic.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I did not like how Bulman classed Hollywood's view of high school into three subgenres that are based primarily socioeconomic standards. I believe today discourse about this topic would rather focus on how these movies can appeal to the typical students of today. Maybe including the revolution of how we consume media online and how it affects our daily lives. Bulman's idea of these three subgenres is kind of like an archaic view to how to appeal to people which would be appealing to stereotypes rather than the individuality we all have.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I couldn’t find anything that I necessarily disagreed with, but I do find a few things very interesting. I do agree with how Bulman said something along the lines of how most teen school movies have the same stereotypical characters and the same plot. I also agree with how Bulman said in most “urban” or black movies that they have the same plot and naïve character, that has to learn or work past some hard ship in the movie. And they have a savor teacher or coach that tries to help them out of said problem. I found it very interesting how there really aren’t as many parody back school movies compared to “suburban” school films. I have noticed that most of the black ones are more serious toned or even dark sometimes and the way that the places and characters are portrayed in those films is very menacing sometimes. But suburban school films take more bubbly and cute, plus the characters joke more.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I disagreed with the sentence on page one that talks about how the making of the movie and how it resonates with certain audiences tells us more about a particular society than the "reality" of a film. I do believe that is true to a certain extent (mainly the resonance of a particular audience with the film) but the development of the stories and characters in these movies do not tell us about a particular society, in my opinion. Bulman later goes on to explain how some of these tropes in high school movies, both in urban and suburban ones, are almost stereotypical (i.e. the dumb jock, the nerd best friend, the heroic teacher, the troubled teens) While some societies may fit these portrayals of high school, others may not, making this a blanket statement.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Although I wasn't able to find much to disagree with, while reading (page four, paragraph 3) I don't completely agree that folktales are the main source of information to help people "remind people the common elements of their culture." I slightly don't agree with this because I feel that folktales aren't often believed or respected, and most people respond better to "facts" about cultures and many other things. I also believe that folktales cannot always been a true representation of culture due to changes in the story over time.

    ReplyDelete
  19. After reading this chapter, I do not totally disagree with Bulman's perspective. I agree with his opinion on how films have the power to influence people's perception of social life (page 3). The first example I can think of is when I see posts online from people in different countries talking about how because of the American movies they watched, they assume life in the US is the same way, when in reality it's not. The only place I did not agree with him was when he discussed his views on individualism.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I found the part where he identified the distinction between the "Suburban" and "Urban" subgenres, through discussing their spoofs, 'Not Another Teen Movie' and 'High School High' respectively. I think he had a very valid point, that the stereotypes we associate with high school movies --jocks, nerds, cheerleaders, etc...-- are only applicable within movies that are set in suburban, middle class, and largely white high schools. While high school movies that take place in an urban setting, often feature a single teacher as the hero, and while not dehumanizing the, often black, kids, they don't try to make them relatable or fully fleshed out characters, but instead use them as a challenge for the "teacher-hero" to conquer.

    I wonder how Bulman would react to newer high school dramas that break these molds like Sex Education or Euphoria.

    ReplyDelete
  21. On page 5 it talks about the different types of high school movies. I agree with the fact that Hollywood movies have major stereotypes and also I also think that they glamorize the high school setting. Although the morals for the movie may be cheesy, the part I disagree with is it doesn't mean they aren't important. Morals such as independence and finding out who you are I think are important lessons. These moral lessons might not be as vital as in other movies, but I still do think they are important.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I disagreed with Bulman's point about how individualism is the root of all high school movies. While this is often one of the main themes for many high school movies, it is impossible to put it as the main theme for every single main character in every single high school movie. It is important to recognize that there are many different themes in these high school movies, and while individualism can play a big role, it doesn't mean that it is the only theme that stands out. For example, there are often other morals, such as working as a team, creating a support system, striving for success, etc. While it is true that often finding one's individualism does play a part, I think there are many more things that can be taken away outside of high school movies just being "coming of age movies" developed around that single theme.

    (This is one of the blog posts I was having so much trouble getting to post!)

    ReplyDelete
  23. I found it very difficult to disagree with anything in the first chapter of Bulman. he basically was stating that tv and movies are something that we make for yourself about ourselves. and this is primarily true. in Bulman he made this comparison about folk tales, but it transfers over. and while tv and movies are magical and imaginative there represent at the very least what people want to see. the only thing that I can't fully agree with is at the very beginning when he states that sociologists don't often study films and I have 2 things to say about this the first is that they study real people not fictional characters. but with that said they can look at the interaction with people and movies and tv and make estimates for how people will react and so on.

    ReplyDelete
  24. One claim in this chapter that I disagreed with was Bulmans statement on individualism being a common theme in high school film. Bulmand says, talking about teen movies, “Individualism is the dominant theme in most of the films”. This statement makes sense in some ways because most high school films make it seem like being different can get you farther in life. Whether that be a nerd that ends up getting a good job or going to a great college or a person with a passion for music/acting from a small town that makes it out. So yes these films do want to be seen as having a theme of individualism but in reality I don't think that is true. Like Bulman says in the beginning of the chapter most high school films have the same story line or characters. Pretty cheerleaders, jocks, nerds or emo outcast kids. And a lot of the time the “outcasts” or “nerds” spend the entire movie trying to fit in or be like the “popular” kids. All the films are the same and say nothing about actually being different or what individualism actually is.

    ReplyDelete

August 29…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...